Roth vs Traditional Calculator
Adjust the inputs below. Results update as you type.
How it works
Traditional 401(k)/IRA contributions reduce taxable income now but are taxed at withdrawal. Roth contributions are after-tax but grow and withdraw tax-free. If your tax rate is lower now than in retirement, Roth wins. If higher now, traditional wins. Most people benefit from having both types for tax diversification in retirement.
Input guidance
- Use realistic rates from lender or provider quotes instead of headline averages.
- Model conservative, baseline, and optimistic scenarios before deciding.
- Include recurring real-world costs (fees, taxes, insurance, maintenance) where relevant.
More examples to test
- Conservative case: use a higher interest rate and lower growth assumptions to stress-test affordability.
- Optimistic case: use a lower rate with stable income assumptions to compare upside potential.
How to interpret results
Treat this as a planning model, not a final approval tool. Compare at least two scenarios and focus on total-cost and cash-flow trade-offs.
When this can be inaccurate
Results can diverge due to fees, changing rates, tax rules, lender policies, and behavior changes that simplified models cannot fully capture.
Change history
- July 2026: Quality-reviewed for publication with formula checks and explanatory copy updates.
Site-wide corrections also appear on the corrections log.
Compare retirement and investing providers
Investment risk applies. Offers vary.
Compare top personal finance offers
Offers and rates vary by eligibility.
Frequently asked questions
How should I use this result?+
Treat it as a planning estimate. Compare at least two realistic scenarios, then confirm with statements, quotes, or a qualified professional before acting.
How often should I refresh assumptions?+
Refresh whenever rates, income, costs, or policy limits change materially, and before making irreversible commitments.